QUOTE (deamhain @ Oct 15 2004, 04:55 AM)
QUOTE (SRVfan2004 @ Oct 14 2004, 08:28 PM)
soloing is where its at my friend
Not sure I entirely agree. The ability to play solo is undoubtedly valuable but the ability to play well with others, to hear what they are doing and where they are going, to play - quite literally - to the beat of someone elses drum, these are the things that make the difference between someone who can play an instrument and a musician.
Given that I only started to learn guitar this year and that I'm no spring chicken any more it's rather doubtful that I'll ever play guitar in a band but I look forward to at least being able to jam with a few friends.
Almost 20 years ago I used to sing with a band and while Steve, Malc and Eric (bass, guitar and drums) could solo at the drop of a hat, there was no better feeling than getting through a new song, start-to-finish, all fitting in with each other and as the last chord died away just looking at each other with a smile, a wink or a nod knowing it worked. If all the guys could do was solo, those magic moments would never have been.
Yes, the ability to work with others who are also skilled and have become so close as a group that a new tune can be performed from start to finish through all the changes merely with a few side-long glances at each other is a great feeling, and all too rare. I think a guitarist should be equally comfortable in either a lead or rhythm position. I'm not a believer in the old "worst guitarist plays rhythm" school of thought. I even tend to think the other way around. A bad lead-guitarist can blow a solo, but a bad rhythm player can blow a tune. A
good rhythm player can actually control the complete "feel" of the tune, depending on how he chooses to accompany it. The bass and lead guitarist can play identical notes, etc and the rhythm player can make it sound like a rock, blues, jazz or country tune at his will, depending on what and how he chooses to play. And of course the ultimate goal being to play a tune that is pleasing to one's self and the listeners, the ability to perform solo, including self-accompanyment in lead and bass, is almost like a Rosetta Stone for the acoustic guitarist. Once he has that ability, he can work well in any of those capacities playing with others. One should try to become a "total guitarist".